Thyroid Supplements Can Do More Harm Than Good

I have seen many patients who take thyroid supplements with the good intention of improving the functioning of their thyroid gland and overall health. Unfortunately, thyroid supplements can have the opposite effect.

There are two types of ingredients in thyroid supplements. The first are ingredients that contain iodine. The ingredients listed may say kelp, bugleweed or bladderwrack. Iodine is the critical component of a thyroid hormone molecule and iodine deficiency is known to cause thyroid dysfunction. However, iodine deficiency in the United States is extremely rare. This is because the American salt supply is fortified with iodine. In fact, the average American gets 300-500 mcg of iodine from their diet every day. This is double or triple the recommended daily allowance for iodine which is 150 mcg per day. If you do want to take an iodine supplement, a standard multivitamin which contains 150 mcg of iodine is sufficient.

Iodine is good for the thyroid, but more is not better. In fact, if you flood the thyroid with iodine, it will stop functioning. This is known as the Wolf-Chaikoff effect. In 1948, Drs. Jan Wolff and Israel Lyon Chaikoff at the University of California found that injections of iodine into rats completely stopped thyroid hormone production in the thyroid gland. In fact, the Wolff–Chaikoff effect is reason why potassium iodide is given in in nuclear emergencies (which emit a lot of radioactive iodine).

The second and even more dangerous ingredient in thyroid supplements is from animal thyroid glands, primarily pig (porcine) and cow (bovine). These products are similar to prescription thyroid medications like Armour thyroid, Nature-throid and NP Thyroid, except they have zero quality control and may contain much more or much less than the dose listed on the label. If you want to take a glandular thyroid supplement, it is better to use one of the branded products with better quality control.

If you’d like to learn more about treatments for thyroid disorders or Hashimoto’s disease please feel free to call us or schedule an appointment with Dr. Isaacs using the online booking tool on this website.

Author
Scott Isaacs, MD Endocrinologist and Weight Loss Specialist

You Might Also Enjoy...

Addressing weight regain after bariatric surgery

The average weight loss for patients who undergo bariatric surgery is around 33% of initial body weight compared to an average weight loss of 10% with anti-obesity medications and 3-5% with a low-calorie diet and lifestyle modification.

Long-term hormonal and metabolic adaptations to weight loss

Weight recidivism occurs because reducing body weight triggers adaptive mechanisms that drive weight regain. Body weight is tightly regulated by hormones from the GI tract, pancreas, and adipose tissue that act primarily in the hypothalamus to regulate foo

What You Need to Know About Fatty Liver

Fatty liver or nonalcoholic fatty liver disease (NAFLD) is a disorder in which too much fat builds up in the liver. Nonalcoholic steatohepatitis (NASH) occurs when that extra fat causes inflammation and scarring of the liver.

If It's Not My Thyroid Then What Is It?

Fatigue, weight gain, mood swings, poor concentration, memory issues, sweating, heart palpitations – your internet search says these are all symptoms of thyroid disease…but what happens when thyroid blood tests are actually normal?